| Type | Player | Year | Company | Card | Comments
|
| I | Puckett | 90 | Fleer | 7 | All-Star Team
|
| I | Puckett | 92 | Ultra | 8-20 | All-Star
|
| A | Puckett | 92 | Score | 6-18 | Fanfest
|
| A | Puckett | 93 | Upper Deck | 34
|
| I | Puckett | 94 | Collectors Choice | 353 | Silver Sig.
|
| I | Puckett | 94 | Collectors Choice | 638 | Silver Sig.
|
| I | Puckett | 94 | Collectors Choice | NO# | Team vs. Team (McRae)
|
| A | Puckett | 95 | Ultra | 76
|
| SS | Puckett | 95 | Pinnacle | 296 | Swingmen
|
| A | Puckett | 95 | Flair | 62
|
| A | Puckett | 96 | Pinnacle | 203
|
| A | Puckett | 96 | Upper Deck | 130
|
| A | Puckett | 96 | SPX | 36
|
| A | Puckett | 96 | Select | 64
|
| A | Puckett | 97 | UD3 | 40
|
| A | Puckett | 97 | Upper Deck | 105
|