| Type | Player | Year | Company | Card | Comments
|
| A | Piazza | 93 | Select | 347 | Rookie
|
| A | Piazza | 93 | Upper Deck | 2 | Rookie
|
| I | Piazza | 94 | Donruss | 2 | Special Edition
|
| I | Piazza | 94 | Upper Deck | 273 | Electric Diamond
|
| A | Piazza | 95 | Flair | 155
|
| I | Piazza | 95 | Donruss | 2-9 | Dominators
|
| I | Piazza | 95 | Topps | LL40 | League Leaders
|
| I | Piazza | 95 | Upper Deck | R18 | Predictor
|
| A | Piazza | 96 | Sportflix | 102 | UC3
|
| I | Piazza | 96 | TSC | PC7 | Prime Cuts
|
| I | Piazza | 96 | Ultra | 8-10 | Rawhide Gold Med.
|
| A | Piazza | 97 | Elite | 7
|
| A | Piazza | 97 | Topps Gallery | 133
|
| A | Piazza | 97 | Pinnacle Certified | 26
|
| A | Piazza | 97 | Finest | 50
|
| I | Piazza | 97 | Ultra | 8-12 | Season Crowns
|
| I | Piazza | 97 | Topps | ILM2 | Inter-League Finest
|